Dec. 28, 2025
Preview of Episode 14: Through the Door and Keep Going
This week, the past stops staying put.
Mags and Amy return to Osprey Island — not as legends, not as kids, but as adults carrying the weight of everything that happened there… and everything that didn’t. What was once a story they survived is now an active problem, unfolding in real time, with other lives caught in its gravity.
As lines blur between rescue and reckoning, old assumptions start to crack. The truth the girls thought they understood begins to shift — reframed by new evidence, new voices, and the uncomfortable realization that history doesn’t just repeat. Sometimes, it edits itself.
Because some places don’t just leave scars.
They rewrite the story around them.
Episode 14 drops Monday December 29.
Preview of Episode 13: Curiouser and Curiouser
This week, Mags and Amy follow a trail that refuses to stay straight.
A disappearance pulls them into an uneasy alliance — one that dredges up old rivalries, buried resentments, and questions they’d very much prefer not to answer out lo…
Preview of Episode 12: Black Cedar
This week, Mags and Amy follow the trail somewhere quieter — and somehow far more disturbing.
Still reeling from the fallout of Episode 11, the girls push beyond Avalon Falls and into spaces designed to look calm, safe, and forg…