Season 1 complete — the case is closed. The story isn’t. Season 2 in development.
March 19, 2026

Preview of Episode 25: Small Town Murder Story

Preview of Episode 25: Small Town Murder Story

A story starts to take shape — not because it’s true, but because it’s useful.

This week, Murder Girls turns the mic over to Minerva, as she assembles her own version of events in a special episode of her podcast — one that reframes the investigation, the town, and Mags and Amy themselves.

What emerges isn’t a confession. It’s a narrative.

As Minerva connects the dots, familiar details begin to shift in meaning. Timing becomes intent. Proximity becomes motive. And the girls — once seen as disruptors — are repositioned as something far more deliberate.

But stories like this don’t just explain what happened.

They decide what matters.

And once a version of events starts to spread, it doesn’t need to be proven.

It just needs to be believed.

As threads converge, a new possibility takes hold. Not that the girls are responsible for Dylan Holt’s death… but that they may have recognized exactly what it would set in motion.

And in Avalon Falls, that distinction may not matter.

Some stories are about what happened.

Others are about who gets to tell it.

Episode 25: Small Town Murder Story drops Monday March 23.

Related Episode

25
March 23, 2026

Small Town Murder Story

This episode, Murder Girls takes a different shape. At Minerva Maddox’s invitation, Mags and Amy sit down for a recorded interview on 'Small Town Murder Story' — her podcast built on versions, narratives, and the quiet power of who gets to tell them. What follows is less a conversation than a negotiation: of memory, of truth, and of the story that has followed them for the past ten years. As Minerva revisits the original case that made the “Murder Girls” infamous, old wounds resurface — along...